Ovarian Cancer: Do Screening Tests Work?

By Debbie Saslow, PhD

For years, patients, doctors, and researchers have been trying to find a way to catch ovarian cancer early, when it’s most treatable. For women, the chance of getting ovarian cancer is about 1 in 70.  In most cases, the cancer is found at an advanced stage and survival is, sadly, quite low.

Most women get tested regularly for breast cancer and cervical cancer, and hopefully colorectal (colon) cancer. Why aren’t they checked for ovarian cancer, too?  Unfortunately we don’t have tests like mammograms or Pap tests for the ovaries. Doctors often do a pelvic exam, which includes checking the ovaries, but this exam rarely finds ovarian tumors unless they have grown very large.

Some other tests, like the CA-125 blood test and transvaginal ultrasound, have been studied to see if they can be used to test for ovarian cancer, but none have proven to be accurate enough to consistently find cancer. [more]

The CA-125 test measures a protein that can be found in the blood of many women with ovarian cancer. However, other conditions, including but not limited to normal ovulation, endometriosis, pelvic inflammatory disease, can also raise CA-125 levels in the blood, and some women with ovarian cancer may still have normal CA-125 levels. And transvaginal ultrasound can find a mass on the ovaries, but it cannot determine whether or not that mass is cancer. That means more invasive tests like biopsies, which carry their own risks, are needed.

Because of these problems, these tests are not recommended for women at average risk, but they may be used for women at high risk or who have symptoms that may suggest ovarian cancer. Even in these women, however, these tests are problematic and their use is limited.

The results of one large recent study looking at whether ovarian cancer screening could find cancers early enough to save lives compared testing women yearly with both CA-125 and ultrasound to no testing. Nearly 80,000 women participated. Three-fourths of the ovarian cancers diagnosed in both the tested group and the untested group were already advanced stage, meaning they had spread to other parts of the body, making treatment difficult. Making things even more problematic, more of the women who had been tested had surgery to remove their ovaries, but it turned out that they did not have ovarian cancer. The surgeries led to severe complications in about 15% of the women, such as heart problems, bowel injury, blood clots, and infection. The bottom line: testing did not save any more lives compared to not testing, did not find cancer at an earlier stage, and led to many more unnecessary surgeries that sometimes resulted in serious complications.

The definitive large ovarian cancer screening study, which is expected to confirm the success or failure of ovarian cancer testing, currently is being done in the United Kingdom. This study, with more than 200,000 women, also compares testing with CA-125 and/or ultrasound to no testing, but women who are at intermediate or high risk of ovarian cancer have repeat CA-125 testing to check for rising levels over time. This is because changes in their CA-125 levels could be a good predictor of which women develop ovarian cancer. The UK study will be completed in 2014.

Are there any newer tests that are more reliable? There has been research and several attempts to develop a blood test for ovarian cancer. These are based on measuring genes or proteins that may be present in higher or lower amounts in women with ovarian cancer compared to women who do not have ovarian cancer. None of these tests has yet been proven to be accurate, effective, or to save lives. No test has been validated (studied in large groups of women to see if it actually helps find ovarian cancer early) nor undergone FDA review.

So without an accurate, recommended screening test, what should women do to protect themselves from ovarian cancer?  Even though ovarian cancer has been called the silent killer, many women with ovarian cancer actually do have symptoms.   These include:

  • Bloating
  • Pelvic or abdominal pain
  • Difficulty eating or feeling full quickly
  • Urinary symptoms (urgency or frequency)

These symptoms are more likely to persist in women with ovarian cancer than women in the general population. However, they are not unique to ovarian cancer, and in fact most women who have these symptoms will not have ovarian cancer. If these symptoms are new and occur repeatedly for at least a month and can’t be explained, an evaluation for ovarian cancer is recommended. However, only an invasive procedure like laparoscopy or open surgery can confirm that a woman has ovarian cancer, and these procedures carry their own serious risk.

The American Cancer Society, other health organizations, and ovarian cancer advocacy groups encourage and fund research to develop an accurate and valid test for early detection of ovarian cancer.  In the meantime, organizations do not recommend screening for women at average risk.

Dr. Saslow is the director of breast and gynecologic cancer for the American Cancer Society.

3 thoughts on “Ovarian Cancer: Do Screening Tests Work?

  1. I have Ovarian Cancer. Not doing well and my prognosis is not good. By the time I had symptoms and they found the cancer it was too late. Why is the CA125 not recommeded unless there are symptoms?????

    For breast cancer they do not wait until the ladies show up with a growth. They recommend mamograms every year. Mamograms do not always pick up breast cancer. But even if a lady finds a cancerous growth…her prognosis is still good.

    This is not true with Ovarian Cancer. The prognosis is not good by the time they find the cancer. Please…please…for the sake of the ladies who as of yet have not been diagnosed with this terrible cancer….please save lives….and put out more information for the public and for Doctors. We are important too……not just ladies with Breast Cancer.

    Last month was Ovarian Cancer Awareness month. There was not much out there about Ovarian Cancer. But you saw advertiesment by the you all over the place.

    We are dying…please care about us too.

  2. Hi, Rosie, thank you for reading the blog and for commenting. I’m so sorry about what you’re going through. Studies are ongoing regarding the CA-125 test, so hopefully one day we’ll have better answers. If you need any information or local resources to help you, please call our National Cancer Information Center anytime of the day or night at 1-800-227-2345, or contact them here: http://www.cancer.org/Aboutus/HowWeHelpYou/app/contact-us.aspx

    Best wishes to you.

  3. Hi, Carole, you should talk to your doctor about your family history and health needs. There is no one answer for this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.